We always stress the importance of choosing the right personal representative for a Last Will and Testament. The ideal candidate is someone impartial, capable, trustworthy, and fair. It isn’t a decision to make lightly.

Why not? Well, consider this story from Forbes. The cast of characters, as they put it, includes:

  • The Deceased — A 92-year-old widow with $12.5 million to her name
  • The Personal Representative (a.k.a. Executor) — The deceased’s cousin, a 73-year-old homemaker with a high school education
  • The Attorney — An older attorney distracted by her own battle with brain cancer
  • The Beneficiaries — 7 distant relatives and 3 charities
  • The IRS — (Well, you already know all about the IRS.)

And here’s what happened, according to Forbes:

When 92-year-old Virginia passed away, she left a simple little three-page will behind. In fact, she’d just had that will drawn up six months prior. When Virginia died, her cousin and personal representative returned to the attorney’s office and asked how to proceed. The lawyer said she’d take care of everything, but in her own private battle with cancer, she forgot.

The personal representative kept getting notices in the mail, but the lawyer assured her that she was filing for an extension and that all was taken care of. All was not taken care of, and eventually the IRS slapped the estate with a $1.2 million fine, consisting of penalties and interest.

The personal representative elicits sympathy, at least. Reportedly a woman of simple means, she’d never even been inside an attorney’s office before. Nevertheless, she and the attorney each found themselves as defendants against a malpractice suit filed by the estate. They settled out of court, and now the personal representative is in the middle of her own legal action, seeking reimbursement from the IRS.

The story just goes to show how important it is to choose the right personal representative and the right estate planning attorney. They could save your family a fortune, not to mention a real pain in the neck.

Disclaimer: This blog post is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading this content does not create an attorney-client relationship. For legal advice specific to your situation, please consult with a qualified attorney.

Tiffany A. O'Connell, JD, LLM, CELA, AEP

About Tiffany A. O'Connell, JD, LLM, CELA, AEP

Tiffany A. O'Connell, JD, LLM, CELA, AEP is the CEO and Founding Partner of O'Connell Law, an estate planning and elder law firm serving clients across Massachusetts, New Hampshire, and Vermont. She is one of a select group of attorneys in Massachusetts certified by the National Elder Law Foundation as a Certified Elder Law Attorney (CELA). Tiffany focuses her practice on estate planning, trust and probate administration, Medicaid planning, long-term care planning, Alzheimer's planning, charitable planning, and retirement and wealth strategies. She has been helping families plan for their futures since opening her practice in 2010.

Credentials: JD, LLM, CELA (Certified Elder Law Attorney — National Elder Law Foundation), AEP (Accredited Estate Planner)

Licensed in: Massachusetts

Areas of Practice: Estate Planning, Elder Law, Medicaid Planning, Probate & Trust Administration, Alzheimer's Planning, Asset Protection

View all posts by Tiffany A. O'Connell, JD, LLM, CELA, AEP →

One Response to “Choosing the Wrong Personal Representative for a Will Could Cost Millions”